I don’t have to make many presentations these days. I have the 34" UW on my main rig and I have 2 24" displays on the laptop, split much the same as you, except Teams on the built-in display (bottom middle), mail/web/reference material right and remote sessions, either servers with RDP or client PCs with TeamViewer and managemnet consoles left - although I do tend to swap the left and right around, when I need access to multiple windows of the same type.
The UW makes a hughe difference, I have the windows side-by-side and if I have something “big”, I can make it full screen (E.g. a big spreadsheet or image editing). The extra vertical space (1440 instead of 1080) makes a huge difference, but you already have that on the 25" monitor (do you have that at 100% or 125% scaling? I used to have a 27" 1440p and that was borderline for me.
And that is my worry, about going to a 32"-34" UHD screen, that I’d have to scale up the desktop. I want to use the extra space, not waste it through zooming everything to make it readable.