How best to organize photos?

What is the best way to import, manage and view photos?

I used to use Lightroom, but switched to Capture One with my Sony. I am now thinking about moving over to Linux and Darktable. That means each time that I have to start from scratch with my images and re-import them.

My collection goes back to the turn of the century and is in various formats and sizes. Before I got heavily into Lightroom, I imported everything into folders: year\month\day-or-shoot (E.g. 2020\03\24-night shoot). I still use this structure to this day, as it is easy to quickly find images I want, regardless of what device I am on and whether my photo management software is available (E.g. on my phone or using a web browser to my NAS or OneDrive).

When I got into shooting raws, I restructured and had the old structure above for the finished results and a separate structure \raws&originals\year\month\day-or-shoot I then copied everything from the above folders into the originals folder and imported everything into Lightroom and later Capture One. I then used the original folder structure for output in JPEG of the processed images in a screen-sized resolution. That meant manageable file sizes and quick loading whilst out and about and the original quality in my management software when I need to retouch a photo, provide a high quality export or for print etc.

Thinking of moving again, I am wondering if the whole set-up I have isn’t too complicated and whether there is a better way. Does anyone have any suggestions, or care to describe their process?

1 Like

I don’t want to put words in @Leo’s mouth, but my guess is he would say “let go and let Google Photos”. i.e. store them in it, and use search to find what you want. Unfortunately for me I am unwilling to trust any private data to any cloud, so I can’t follow that advice. For me, I just dump them in a folder and hope magic occurs. Strangely, it never does, and I have a mess. :worried:

The same here. No way I would use Google and I am less and less enamoured by Microsoft and OneDrive… I already have everything on my NAS as data and a backup (different LUNs) and I am considering putting NextCloud on a small server in the network and using that for storage.

Google Photo also doesn’t do RAW (or is very finicky about the formats it accepts). As 90% of my photos are in RAW format, using Google Photo is a non starter, even if I would trust my photos to Google. There were also some problems about RAW not being in the “free” tier. I already have 1TB of OneDrive with Office 365, which is the only reason I use it as a backup medium.

I pretty much use your old structure. Regardless of jpg or raw. Exports are kept in an exports directory within the same structure. Works for me, may not for others. Tagging definitely helps.

I keep all my originals in a file/folder structure similar to yours, backed up to NAS/removable storage/iDrive. Additionally I upload them to iCloud for easy viewing on my devices and sharing with others. If a photo needs editing/printing/etc I’ll source the original.

1 Like

Back when I had a “proper” camera, I used Photoshop Elements to categorise by location etc. I’ve given up on that and have relied on Google Photos and custom tagging to find what I want.

1 Like